Console Quarterly

Back to the full UK games guide

Crime adventure · 18+ readership

Mafia: Definitive Edition

A focused period crime story.

Editorial score8.3/10
A fictional 1930s city street with a period sedan and warm street lamps

Our editorial overview

Tommy Angelo’s story in the fictional 1930s city of Lost Heaven is the main reason to choose Mafia: Definitive Edition. This remake of the first Mafia story suits a player who likes the idea of returning to the same characters over several evenings and wants a period setting to give the story a clear identity.

If you are comparing crime games by the amount of free exploration they encourage, factor in how central the campaign is here. It is a better fit for an evening where you want to see the next part of a specific story than for a routine built around open-ended repeat visits. Check the full edition name before buying or comparing advice, since conversations about the first Mafia may refer to either release.

At a glance

A remake of the first Mafia story, following Tommy Angelo in the fictional 1930s city of Lost Heaven.

Before choosing: Its story-led structure differs from a large repeatable sandbox.

Pros
Lost Heaven and Tommy’s journey give the remake a focused period crime story to follow.
Consider
A story-led structure offers fewer reasons for open-ended returns once the central campaign has served its purpose.

How we choose and score games

Scores are editorial assessments based on the cited product information and the weighted rubric below. Use them alongside genre, edition details and the kind of session you want. A higher score can still be a poor fit for your preferences.

  • Gameplay (35%)
  • Presentation (25%)
  • Story / world (20%)
  • Replay value (10%)
  • Accessibility (10%)

Each criterion is assessed on a ten-point scale. The weighted result is rounded to one decimal place. Our selection covers paid games for an adult readership; check each product’s own age classification.

Where to play and check requirements

Confirm the exact edition, supported devices, local availability and age classification on the product page before making a purchase.

Official product information for Mafia: Definitive Edition

Read another review